cursor
h a t t a n m e d a
Get a quote
  • AI

AI chatbot on your website: when it pays off and when to skip it

An AI chat assistant earns its place on your website when two things are true: your site already holds the answers customers ask for, and someone on your team will read its transcripts each month. If either is missing, an FAQ page and a contact form do the job with less risk.

You answer for what the bot tells a customer, and one tribunal has already ruled that way.

What a chat assistant does well

A chat assistant answers the questions your site already answers, including late on a Sunday night. Hours, parking, return windows, what to bring to a first appointment: if the answer sits on a page, a well-configured bot saves the visitor the hunt.

It can also qualify a lead. Give it the questions your staff ask first, such as the type of job and the timing, and it collects the answers and passes the transcript to a person. If the tool connects to your calendar, the visitor can book a call before leaving the site.

Where it goes wrong

These assistants write fluent sentences with or without facts behind them. Ask one about a price your site doesn't list and it may produce a number anyway, and the same goes for refund terms and stock levels. Your customer can't tell a grounded answer from an invented one.

Stale content causes the second kind of error. A bot that reads last year's price sheet repeats last year's prices. Air Canada's bot contradicted the airline's own policy page, and the dispute reached a tribunal.

What the Air Canada decision held

In November 2022 a customer asked the chatbot on Air Canada's website about bereavement fares. The bot said they could submit their ticket for the reduced rate within 90 days of issue. Air Canada's policy page said the airline did not accept requests after travel, and the airline did not pay.

The customer went to British Columbia's Civil Resolution Tribunal, which decided Moffatt v. Air Canada on February 14, 2024.

Air Canada argued it could not be held liable for information its chatbot provided. The tribunal member called that "a remarkable submission" and wrote:

"It should be obvious to Air Canada that it is responsible for all the information on its website. It makes no difference whether the information comes from a static page or a chatbot."

The tribunal found negligent misrepresentation. Air Canada had not taken reasonable care to make its chatbot accurate, and the customer had no reason to double-check one part of the website against another.

It ordered the airline to pay $650.88 in damages, $812.02 in total with interest and tribunal fees, in Canadian dollars.

This is a Canadian small-claims decision and it does not bind a US court. Take the reasoning as a warning: a judge may treat your chatbot's answer the same as a sentence on your pricing page.

What US regulators and state laws say

This section is general information, not legal advice. Chatbot laws are changing fast, so check with your lawyer before you rely on any of it.

Federal: when the FTC announced a sweep of AI cases called Operation AI Comply in September 2024, then-Chair Lina Khan said "there is no AI exemption from the laws on the books." Those cases went after companies' claims about AI products, not a shop's wrong answer.

In August 2025 the FTC sued Air AI, alleging it sold "conversational AI" to small businesses with claims that it could replace human customer service staff, along with earnings promises and refund guarantees it did not honor. Air AI settled in March 2026. Read a chatbot vendor's promises with that case in mind.

New Jersey: a law approved in January 2020 says a person may not use an online bot to communicate with someone in New Jersey "in connection with the sale or advertisement of any merchandise or real estate" unless they disclose at the outset, clearly and conspicuously, that a bot is doing the talking.

It defines a bot as "an automated online account where all or substantially all of the actions or posts of that account are not directly generated by a live natural person." Penalties are $2,500 for a first offense, $5,000 for a second and $10,000 for each one after. Ask your lawyer how that definition applies to a chat widget.

New York: on October 28, 2026, the governor signed a chatbot law that takes effect January 1, 2027. The bill text bars operators from offering a list of "unsafe AI companion features," such as output suggesting the system is human, unless they have confirmed the user is not a minor.

It covers a generative AI system with a "natural language interface" that gives "ongoing, adaptive responses to user inputs." A bot offered solely for customer service or product information is exempt, "provided that the covered AI companion is unable to respond on topics outside of the specified purpose."

The attorney general can seek up to $25,000 per violation. Ask your vendor in writing if its bot can be confined to your business that way.

Maine and other states: Maine's 2025 law bars using an AI chatbot in trade and commerce in a way that may mislead a reasonable consumer into thinking they are dealing with a human, unless you tell them clearly that they are not. Other states have their own versions, and DLA Piper's January 2026 summary compares them.

Six rules for running one

  • Limit it to your own content. Set it to answer only from your pages and documents, and to say "I don't have that, here is how to reach us" for everything else.
  • Show its sources. Each answer should link to the page it came from. The customer can check it, and you can see which page needs fixing.
  • Hand off to a person. Quotes, complaints, refunds and anything contractual go to a human. Keep a phone number or email visible inside the chat window.
  • Log conversations. In the Air Canada case the customer's screenshot of the bot's answer was in evidence. Keep your own record, and say in your privacy policy that you save chats.
  • Tell visitors it is automated. Put it in the first message.
  • Review it monthly. Read a sample of transcripts, fix the page behind each wrong answer, and retest after each price or policy change.

When an FAQ page and a contact form are enough

Skip the bot if you get a few inquiries a week. You take on a cost and a monthly review chore to automate conversations you could answer yourself in ten minutes.

A bot is also a poor fit when your answers depend on judgment. A contractor who prices each job after a site visit has nothing safe for a bot to say about cost. A quote calculator with your own formula behind it gives a number you control.

Wait if your site is thin, because a bot limited to your content can only repeat what you have written. Write the FAQ page first: it helps visitors today and gives a future bot something to draw on. The same material helps get your business into AI search answers.

What to do this week

  1. List the 20 questions customers ask most. Pull them from your inbox and your front desk.
  2. Check that each one has a current written answer on your site. Fix the gaps before anything else.
  3. If you run a bot now, ask it those 20 questions and five more about prices and policies. Screenshot each wrong answer.
  4. Read its first message. It should say the chat is automated and show how to reach a person.
  5. Ask your vendor in writing: can the bot be restricted to our content, does it cite its sources, and how long do you keep transcripts?
  6. Put a monthly transcript review on one named person's calendar.

HattanMedia builds websites and custom web tools such as quote builders. If you want your site's answers in order before a bot starts repeating them, see our services or contact us.

All articles

More from the blog

AI

AI website builder, template, freelancer or agency: how to choose

An AI builder is the right answer for a simple site this week. Here is where it stops, and what a freelancer or an agency adds.

Search

Google Business Profile checklist for New York businesses

What Google says affects local ranking, how to set up each part of your Business Profile, and the mistakes that get a profile suspended.

Search

How to get your business mentioned in AI search answers

How ChatGPT, Google's AI answers, Perplexity and Copilot pick sources, what to fix on your site this week, and which tactics are hype.